Food heritage
This page summarizes dated food-and-drink history from the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis and from official city descriptions of downtown cultural districts.[1][2][3][5] It does not recommend restaurants, rank dishes, or publish a dining directory. A general encyclopedia article titled Food and Drink was not available at the URL checked for this wiki.
A downtown building from 1850
The Slippery Noodle Inn, at the corner of South and Meridian streets, is described in the Encyclopedia of Indianapolis as the oldest standing commercial building in the metropolitan area.[1] The inn was built in 1850 as a roadhouse called the Tremont House.[1] In the 1860s it became the Concordia House, described there as the first German American club in Indianapolis, and was later called the Germania House.[1] During World War I, owner Louis Beck changed the name to Beck's Saloon.[1] Walter Moore ran it before Prohibition as Moore's Beer Tavern and during Prohibition as Moore's Restaurant.[1] Harold (Hal) and Lorean Yeagy bought the inn in 1963 and gave it its current name; after Hal Yeagy died in 1984, Hal Yeagy Jr. converted the business into a blues venue the following year.[1] The city's official Wholesale District description names the Slippery Noodle Inn among downtown landmarks, together with Union Station, Gainbridge Fieldhouse, and the Indianapolis Arts Garden.[5] Those mentions are recorded as named landmarks, not as reviews.
St. Elmo Steak House
In October 1902, Joe Stahr opened St. Elmo Steak House on South Illinois Street, naming it for the patron saint of sailors.[2] Stahr sold the restaurant in 1947 to Burt Condon, who sold it in 1948 to Harry Roth and his brothers, Sam and Ike.[2] In 1956, Isadore (Izzy) Rosen teamed up with Harry Roth; they sold the business in 1986 to Stephen M. Huse and Jeff Dunaway.[2] The encyclopedia records the address as 127 S. Illinois Street and notes that in 2007 Huse opened a related restaurant named Harry & Izzy's in honor of former owners.[2] The encyclopedia's Wholesale District article also names St. Elmo among historic establishments in that district.[6] Claims that the restaurant is the oldest steak house in the city, or that a particular dish is the most popular, are the encyclopedia's or promoters' statements and are not adopted here as independent rankings.
Drive-in restaurants
The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis dates automobile curb service in the city to the 1930s.[3] Henry Mewborn opened the Peacock in early 1930 at 38th Street and Massachusetts Avenue, described as the first restaurant in the city to serve patrons in their cars.[3] In 1932, A. R. McComb built the Wigwam next to the Indiana State Fairgrounds; the building was newly constructed in 1939, renamed the Tee Pee, and stood until 1988.[3] Spencer's North Pole was built in 1937; in 1952 its name and location were changed to the Pole at 16th Street and Lafayette Road.[3] The Ron-D-Vu opened to Butler University students in 1940.[3] The encyclopedia says the popularity of drive-ins peaked in the 1950s and 1960s and declined in the 1970s as fast-food businesses with drive-up windows spread.[3] It names Edward's, open since 1957, among drive-ins that remained in operation when that article was written.[3]
Mug-n-Bun and the first Indiana Steak 'n Shake
Mug-n-Bun, at 5211 W. 10th Street in Speedway, is described as one of Indianapolis's oldest continuously operating drive-in restaurants.[7] The dedicated encyclopedia article says it opened as a Frostop drive-in in 1956.[7] A separate drive-ins article dates Mug 'n Bun to 1960.[3] This page reports both dates rather than choosing one. After a later owner expanded the menu beyond standard Frostop fare, the article names tenderloins, onion rings, fish, and a sweeter root-beer recipe among the additions.[7]
A. H. "Gus" Belt founded Steak 'n Shake in Normal, Illinois, in February 1934.[4] After Belt died in August 1954, his widow, Edith Belt, assumed ownership, and three months later the first Steak 'n Shake in Indiana opened as a drive-in restaurant in Indianapolis.[4] The drive-ins article places that first Indianapolis drive-in at Lafayette and Tibbs roads in 1954.[3] Edith Belt sold the business in 1969; the encyclopedia says later owner E. W. Kelley and Associates moved the headquarters from Illinois to Indiana in 1981.[4]
What this page leaves out
Lists of current restaurants, signature dishes presented as recommendations, and unsourced origin stories are omitted. Named businesses appear here only because they are documented in the cited encyclopedia articles or on an official city district page, and only with the dates and ownership changes those sources provide.
Common questions
Is this a restaurant guide?
No. It is a historical summary of food-and-drink places and forms that are documented in cited public sources. It does not recommend where to eat.
When did drive-in restaurants begin in Indianapolis?
The Encyclopedia of Indianapolis dates the first in-car service to early 1930, when Henry Mewborn opened the Peacock at 38th Street and Massachusetts Avenue.[3]
How old is the Slippery Noodle Inn building?
The encyclopedia says the building was constructed in 1850 as the Tremont House.[1]
Related pages
- Culture
- The Children's Museum of Indianapolis
- Newfields
- Eiteljorg Museum
- Indianapolis Symphony Orchestra
- Indianapolis Cultural Trail
References
All sources retrieved November 2026, unless a source is dated in the text.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j "Slippery Noodle Inn". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ a b c d e f g "St. Elmo Steak House". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m "Drive-In Restaurants". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ a b c d e "Steak 'n Shake". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ a b "Cultural Districts". City of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ "Wholesale District". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.
- ^ a b c "Mug-n-Bun". Encyclopedia of Indianapolis. Retrieved November 2026.